Canada on Big Muddy

Adjusting for recalled past vote in political polling

Sun, 12 Apr 2026 22:55:00 -0400

The founder of Abacus Data, a Canadian polling firm, dropped kind of an interesting URL yesterday: abacus-weighting.com. It’s a advertisement in the form of a case study on why Abacus weights their political polls on past vote. It fits perfectly with the theme of yesterday’s post on how pollster’s get different results from the same data (the answer is they weight the raw data differently).

If you follow Nate Silver (or American political polling in general), you probably know that pollsters undercounted Trump support in all three elections where he was on the ballot. What I learned from this post is that support for the Conservative Party of Canada has been underestimated in their firm’s polling data in every polling wave for every election since 2011:

In every single wave, across every single election cycle, Conservative voters are underrepresented in our demographically weighted sample relative to their actual share of the vote. Not in most waves. Not in some elections. In every case we can observe.

Weighting for recalled past vote improves the estimate in every case, sometimes dramatically so:

In every election, past vote weighting moved our Conservative estimates upward and our Liberal estimates downward — consistently in the direction of the actual result. The 2021 election shows the most dramatic correction: a 7-point improvement in our Conservative estimate.

The triumph of the data raccoons

Fri, 03 Apr 2026 23:40:00 -0400

My PhD co-supervisor at the University of Toronto, Dr. David Fisman, liked to use the term “data raccoon” to describe the work of using messy, incomplete, hard-to-work-with data to do serious research. Or, as he described it in testimony to the Canadian House of Commons in May 2020 (emphasis mine):

I’ll tell you, my group at University of Toronto call ourselves “data raccoons”, because we’ve sort of managed to thrive for about 15 years on data that most people regard as garbage, so it’s sort of a bit of the normal state of affairs for us with public health data analysis.

It’s an unmistakably Toronto metaphor—the city isn’t called the raccoon capital of the world for nothing!

It occurred to me recently that data raccoons have basically taken over the world. The basis of the AI revolution is vast quantities of text dredged from the Internet, none of which was written for its final purpose of training the deus ex machina. Arguably the most important dataset for training LLMs has been Common Crawl, a mostly uncurated snapshot of the Internet that has been running since 2007. According to a Mozilla report from 2024, Common Crawl was used in two thirds of LLMs developed in the formative period between 2019 and 2023, and the archive also comprised 80% of tokens in OpenAI’s GPT-3. Unsurprisingly, the Common Crawl Foundation has received financial support from AI companies in recent years, all the while being accused of abetting these same companies to train their models on paywalled articles.

One important fact about for-profit plasma donation

Mon, 30 Mar 2026 21:51:00 -0400

For-profit plasma donation is in the news today in Canada. Two people recently died after giving plasma at Grifols for-profit plasma clinics in Winnipeg, Manitoba, although Health Canada has yet to find a link between the plasma collections and the deaths. Today, it was reported that a Grifols clinic in Calgary, Alberta was found non-compliant during an inspection in December 2025:

The inspection found the Calgary centre didn’t accurately assess whether donors were suitable, didn’t collect blood according to its Health Canada authorization, didn’t thoroughly investigate errors and accidents, and didn’t carry out sufficient corrective and preventative actions.

This is obviously a problem for for-profit plasma collection in Canada, where the practice is already controversial. Paid plasma collection is illegal in Canada’s three largest provinces: Ontario, British Colombia, and Quebec, though Ontario allows a few for-profit clinics to operate through an agreement with Canadian Blood Services, Canada’s independent blood authority. British Colombia and Quebec together make up over 35% of Canada’s population; including Ontario, it’s nearly 80%. Besides Ontario, for-profit clinics exist in some other smaller provinces.

Vocal advocacy exists against paid plasma collection, leading to municipal resolutions against the practice in Ontario, even as clinics open. This advocacy is often premised on the fear that paid plasma will undermine voluntary donations. To my mind, the central fact in the for-profit plasma collection debate is that only a handful of countries are self-sufficient in plasma collection, and all of them allow for paid plasma collection. They are: the United States, Germany, Czechia, Austria, and Hungary (Egypt may have also recently joined the list). While other countries, like Canada, may have achieved self-sufficiency for plasma for direct infusion, no other country can meet its own needs for plasma-derived medical products. The world relies on a small number of self-sufficient countries, primarily the United States, to meet the demand for plasma products.

Prediction markets are coming to Canada

Wed, 25 Mar 2026 21:00:00 -0400

(Archive link to this story)

Wealthsimple is a fintech company at the forefront of a lot of innovation in Canada’s personal finance sector since the company’s founding in 2014. Notably, Wealthsimple was the first broker in Canada to offer zero-commission trades, back in 2019. In 2020, they started offering the ability to trade crypto. In 2025, they launched zero-commission options trading. This year, the company received regulatory approval to bring prediction trading to Canada.

Unlike in other parts of the world, prediction markets have not flourished in Canada and have been considered basically illegal since a 2017 ruling from Canada’s federal securities regulator. Wealthsimple has been able to get around this ruling by only offering contracts on a narrow set of questions:

Despite a 2017 ruling that largely banned these kinds of short-term, yes-or-no contracts, certain regulated firms that are CIRO members are able to offer certain types of “event contracts,” […] The approval for Ontario-based Wealthsimple permits it only to offer contracts tied to economic indicators, financial markets and climate trends, the company confirmed – not sports or elections, which are among the most popular uses of prediction markets in the United States.

Wealthsimple has driven innovation in the Canadian personal finance sector; however, their new product offerings over the last few years seem to be speedrunning the Robinhood trajectory toward high-risk, high-volatility trading and away from their traditional niche of broad, diversified funds/ETFs for ordinary people to set-and-forget. This pivot can be understood as part of a broader trend toward the casinofication of everything, which took off with crypto and the legalization of online sports betting.

Will AI help Canadian police counter a tsunami of fraud?

Tue, 24 Mar 2026 21:48:00 -0400

Zak Vescera, writing for the Investigative Journalism Foundation, observes that fraud cases reported to Canadian police has more than doubled between 2013 and 2024:

At the same time, the number of cases cleared by Canadian police has fallen. In 2013, the ratio between reported cases and cleared cases was about 3:1; by 2024, this ratio was over 9.5:1.

The vast majority of fraud cases go unsolved. This is unsurprising given that many are perpetrated over the Internet by individuals overseas and involve methods of sending money that are difficult to recover, such as crypto, gift cards, and physical transfers of cash.

In response, the National Cybercrime Coordination Centre (NC3) of the RCMP—Canada’s national police service—have built a case management system and data portal they hope will eventually be adopted by all Canadian police forces. According to the article, this system is aimed at improving coordination, data sharing, and analysis. The platform will also host a set of AI tools, though the RCMP is vague on details and which are currently implemented. The article gives a few examples: OCR allowing victims to scan gift cards used in fraud rather than typing numbers manually, a tool to classify reports to help police target their investigative resources, and a report generator to simply data sharing when investigations go international.

Properly the work of federal public health agencies

Sun, 22 Mar 2026 23:38:00 -0400

One of the reasons I started this blog was to have a place to put down posts and articles that have lodged themselves in my brain. The wind-down announcement of the COVID Tracking Project, a volunteer-led COVID-19 data tracking collaboration, is one such article.

But the work itself—compiling, cleaning, standardizing, and making sense of COVID-19 data from 56 individual states and territories—is properly the work of federal public health agencies. Not only because these efforts are a governmental responsibility—which they are—but because federal teams have access to far more comprehensive data than we do, and can mandate compliance with at least some standards and requirements.

After one year of work, the COVID Tracking Project decided to quite collecting data on COVID-19 in the United States, because they recognized that the work of collecting a comparable, national-level dataset was the responsibility of federal government agencies.

As someone who co-led the COVID-19 Canada Open Data Working Group, which curated COVID-19 data for Canada until the end of 2023, I think about this article a lot. It’s a good read, and it speaks to how essential open data was to filling in the gaps in the national and international understanding of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Manitoba introduces bill to ban algorithmic price discrimination

Wed, 18 Mar 2026 07:30:00 -0400

The Canadian province of Manitoba has introduced a bill to ban algorithmic price discrimination (also known as surveillance pricing), i.e., the use of personal data to set prices for individual consumers:

New Democrats announced in December they would begin cracking down on what’s known as differential or predatory pricing. That is when retailers charge different amounts for the same products based on the timing of customer purchases, where they live or other personal data. […] The proposed legislation would render the use of “personalized algorithmic pricing,” both online or in store, an unfair business practice.

Okay, I guess there’s a lot of different names for this particular practice. Whatever we call it, I believe bills cracking down on algorithmic price discrimination will be very popular, as it constitutes a very clear example of companies using our data against us to rip us off. The most famous recent exposé of this practice is Groundwork Collaborative’s report on how grocery delivery service Instacart charges users different prices depending on who they are.

Manitoba isn’t the only jurisdiction introducing bills targeting this practice, but I don’t believe anywhere in the US or Canada has actually managed to ban it yet. However, New York has made in mandatory for companies to disclose when they use personal data to set prices.

Open banking comes to Canada

Thu, 12 Mar 2026 22:03:00 -0400

Canada’s banking sector is legendarily stable. However, this stability comes at the cost of innovation. Canada lags behind peers such as the EU, UK, US, and Australia in an area I care a lot about: open banking.

The premise of open banking is that consumers should be free to share their financial data with the third parties of their choosing, such as a budgeting app.. I have been following open banking in Canada for years now, ever since I started closing tracking my own finances. For a long time, I have been looking for a better way to export transactions than logging into my bank’s website and manually downloading a CSV file representing a certain time range.

Over the years, people have tried to solve this problem by writing third-party packages to retrieve data from specific banks. However, these packages were fragile and prone to breaking, and they usually relied on you providing your full account credentials, granting them to ability to impersonate a login to your account. Shockingly, this is actually the default security model for Canadian fintech companies: even a humble budget app must be given your username, password, and (implicitly) the ability to take any action on your behalf. Needless to say, this is at best a grey zone for liability, since you are willingly handing over the keys to the kingdom to a third party.

Canada exports a lot of coal, but not for power generation

Sun, 08 Mar 2026 14:05:00 -0400

This provocatively titled piece in the The Hub (“Why the world needs even more Canadian coal”) made me realize I know very little about one of Canada’s most important exports: coal.

Coal is often villainized because it is incredibly dirty way of generating power. I vaguely recall an article from maybe 20 years ago claiming something along the lines of “if everyone in Canada replaced their incandescent bulbs with energy-efficient ones, the greenhouse gas savings would be cancelled out by a single coal plant that China is building every [some shockingly short amount of time]”. Although, China’s dependence on coal for power has been falling for the past two decades.

It turns out LLM-assisted search is fantastic for finding these half-remembered quotes. Here is the exact article and quote I was remembering, from a 2008 Macleans magazine article (I was pretty close):

Even if every household in the U.S. screwed in an energy-efficient light bulb today, the savings in greenhouse gas emissions would be wiped out by fewer than two medium-sized coal plants - the kind of plant that is being built in China at a rate of one a week.

But coal is also used to make most of the world’s steel (“metallurgical coal”), and this is the kind of coal that Canada (or specifically, British Columbia) overwhelmingly exports. The article goes on to claim that Canada’s production of metallurgical coal is among the cleanest (by greenhouse gas emissions) in the world.

Open By Default: A database of access to information requests to the Canadian government

Sat, 07 Mar 2026 14:32:00 -0500

In Canada, any person or corporation in the country can make a request for general records to any agency of the federal government through the Access to Information Act (the equivalent in the United States is the Freedom of Information Act). The government provides a searchable database of completed requests, but includes only a summary of the request and the number of pages of responsive material. The actual documents turned over are not included. However, completed request packages may be informally re-requested, and should you do so, someone from the relevant agency will (usually) send them to you eventually.

This re-request process has its limits. It can takes weeks or months for the documents to be sent, and the database itself only goes back to January 2020 (they used to delete records older than two years, but stopped doing this some time after 2020). Occasionally, they will never send the documents at all, and all you can do is either re-request them again or open a formal access to information request (which will cost you $5).

Making it easier to access completed access to information requests is why the Investigative Journalism Foundation built Open By Default, “the biggest database of internal government documents never before made publicly accessible”. It includes documents from completed access to information requests obtained using both automated (presumably the re-request form) and manual processes (donations from trusted partners, particularly of documents from before the online re-request form was available). The files are cleaned and OCRed into one beautiful, searchable database.

The surprising whimsy of the Time Zone Database

Fri, 06 Mar 2026 21:07:00 -0500

Time zones are hard. As a well-known Computerphile video so eloquently puts it:

What you learn after dealing with time zones, is that what you do is you put away your code, you don’t try and write anything to deal with this. You look at the people who have been there before you. You look at the first people, the people who have dealt with this before, the people who have built the spaghetti code, and you thank them very much for making it open source, and you give them credit, and you take what they have made and you put it in your program, and you never ever look at it again. Because that way lies madness.

The Canadian province of British Columbia recently decided to switch to permanent daylight time. I wanted to see if this update made it to the IANA Time Zone Database yet. Luckily, we can now view updates to this database as commits on GitHub. And there it was in the news file!

I’ve perused the tz repository before, and I always learn something interesting. For example, during WWII Britain adopted double summer time, adding two hours to the clock in the summer and one hour in the winter. The bulk of the comments in the database are dedicated to documenting this extensive history of time zone changes across the world.